RRSP vs TFSA vs FHSA: Which Account Should You Open First?
Canada gives newcomers three powerful registered accounts — and most people open the wrong one first. Here's a clear priority framework based on your income and goals.
What Each Account Actually Does
TFSA — Tax-Free Savings Account
- Every dollar you earn inside a TFSA grows completely tax-free, forever
- Withdrawals are never taxed and can be re-contributed the following year
- You accumulate contribution room from the year you turn 18 and become a Canadian resident
- 2024 annual limit: $7,000 (cumulative room if you've been a resident since 2009: $95,000)
- No income requirements — works at any income level
RRSP — Registered Retirement Savings Plan
- Contributions reduce your taxable income in the year you contribute
- Growth is tax-deferred — you pay tax when you withdraw (ideally in retirement, at a lower rate)
- Contribution room = 18% of your previous year's earned income, up to $31,560 (2024 limit)
- Withdrawals are added to your income — timing matters
- Newcomers do not accumulate RRSP room before becoming Canadian residents
FHSA — First Home Savings Account
- Brand new as of 2023 — designed specifically to help Canadians buy their first home
- Combines the best of both: contributions are tax-deductible (like RRSP) and withdrawals are tax-free (like TFSA) when used to buy a qualifying home
- Annual limit: $8,000, lifetime limit: $40,000
- Must be a first-time homebuyer (cannot have owned a home you lived in within the past 4 years)
- Unused annual room carries forward by $8,000 (maximum)
The Priority Framework
If You're Earning Under ~$55,000/year → Start with TFSA
At lower incomes, your marginal tax rate is modest. RRSP deductions aren't as valuable — a $5,000 RRSP contribution only saves you ~$750 in taxes at a 15% marginal rate. Your TFSA grows tax-free and gives you flexible access to cash without triggering income.
Open a TFSA first. Fill it with low-cost index funds (VEQT or XEQT) or a high-interest savings account if you'll need the money soon.
If You're Planning to Buy a Home Within 5 Years → Open the FHSA Immediately
The FHSA is time-sensitive. The sooner you open it, the more room you accumulate. If you open it today and buy a home in 3 years, you could have deposited up to $32,000 (4 years × $8,000) and claimed every dollar as a tax deduction — while your withdrawals are completely tax-free.
Open the FHSA the moment you arrive in Canada if homeownership is even a 5-year possibility. You don't have to contribute the full $8,000 right away — just open it to start the clock.
If You're Earning Over ~$90,000/year → Prioritize RRSP
At higher income brackets (Ontario's combined marginal rate hits 43.41% at $100,000), an RRSP deduction is worth serious money. Every $1,000 contributed saves you $434 in taxes. Invest that refund back into the RRSP and you're compounding a significant tax advantage.
Contribute to RRSP, reinvest the refund, and let time do the work.
The Newcomer Wrinkle: Contribution Room
You accumulate TFSA room from the day you become a Canadian resident. RRSP room is based on your previous year's Canadian earned income — so your first year in Canada, you likely have little to no RRSP room.
Most newcomers should open a TFSA and FHSA in Year 1, then layer in RRSP contributions as their income grows.
The Three-Account Stack (The Ideal Setup)
| Account | Priority | Why |
| FHSA | Open immediately | Tax deduction + tax-free growth, clock starts now |
| TFSA | Fill next | Tax-free growth, flexible withdrawals |
| RRSP | Add once income > $55K | Powerful at higher marginal rates |
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Over-contributing to RRSP at low income: You're trading a small deduction now for taxable withdrawals later
- Not opening FHSA early enough: You can't backfill missed years (only 1 year carries forward)
- Keeping cash in a chequing account instead of a TFSA: Even a high-interest savings account inside a TFSA beats a regular account
- Withdrawing TFSA and not tracking re-contribution room: You get the room back January 1 of the following year — not immediately
Quick Action Plan
- Day 1: Open a TFSA and FHSA at your bank or Wealthsimple
- Contribute $500–$1,000 to each to get started (even small amounts start the compounding clock)
- File your taxes — you'll need a Notice of Assessment to confirm RRSP room
- Revisit your strategy each January when new contribution room opens
Three accounts, one priority order, and years of tax-free compounding ahead of you.
Written by Raunaq Singh, Founder of Maple Syrup Money.
Join the Discussion
Have thoughts on this article? Share your questions, experiences, or insights with the community.